Pregnancy Issues Continue to Expand: Company Fired Pregnant Employee For Her Own Good

by Marti Cardi, Esq. - Senior Compliance Consultant and Legal Counsel

February 17, 2017


Enforcement and legislative attention continue to increase around pregnant employees and pregnancy-related conditions in the workplace.  The message to employers?  Treat a pregnant employee poorly – or differently – at your peril.  Rooms to Go learned this lesson recently, even though the pregnant employee’s manager seemed to be acting in the employee’s best interest.

The Case.  RTG Furniture Corp. (RTG) operates a chain of Rooms to Go furniture stores and distribution centers nationwide.  After being sued by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), the company has agreed to pay $55,000 and provide other relief.

According to the EEOC’s complaint, the company hired Chantoni McBryde on June 1, 2015, and assigned her to work as a shop apprentice at the company’s temporary training facility in Dunn, N.C. The job required the use of various chemicals to repair furniture. On June 3, McBryde informed the company’s shop trainer that she was pregnant. Later that same day, McBryde was called into a meeting with the company’s regional shop manager and others and was asked to confirm that she was pregnant. The EEOC said that during the meeting, the regional shop manager showed McBryde a can of lacquer thinner that contained a warning that the contents could potentially pose a risk to a woman or her unborn child, and discussed the warning with McBryde. The EEOC said that McBryde was then told that because she was pregnant, she could no longer work at the facility.  If true, this conduct violates Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended by the Pregnancy Discrimination Act (PDA), which prohibits employers from terminating workers because they are pregnant.

As is common in settlements of EEOC lawsuits, the company agreed to other provisions in addition to providing monetary relief to McBryde.  The three-year consent decree between RTG and the EEOC requires RTG to develop and implement a policy that prohibits pregnancy-based discrimination; to conduct annual pregnancy discrimination training for employees, supervisors, and managers at certain facilities; to post a notice about the lawsuit and employee rights under federal anti-discrimination laws at those same facilities; and to provide periodic reports to the EEOC.  Thus, while the $55,000 judgment may seem like something your company could handle, this type of extensive oversight and training obligation is far more intrusive and onerous.

According to the EEOC, “Pregnant women have the right to make their own decisions about working while pregnant, including the risks they are willing to assume.  If there may be a potential health concern, it is up to the woman and her doctors to evaluate. Companies must not impose paternalistic notions on pregnant women, as doing so can result in unlawful discrimination.”  EEOC Press Release 02-03-2017

Sources of Pregnancy Protections.  Here are some of the state and federal laws that provide protections for pregnant workers:

  • The federal Pregnancy Discrimination Act, passed in 1978 as an amendment to Title VII, prohibits sex discrimination
    on the basis of pregnancy. Pregnant women who are able to work must be permitted to work
    under the same conditions and must be treated the same as non-pregnant employees.  The EEOC will
    broadly interpret when pregnancy-related conditions are considered disabilities under ADA.
  • The federal Family and Medical Leave Act defines a “serious health condition” to include pregnancy and provides up
    to 12 weeks of leave for prenatal care and pregnancy-related conditions.
  • Under the Americans with Disabilities Act, a “normal pregnancy” is not a disability – but a “pregnancy-related
    impairment that substantially limits a major life activity” can be a disability.
  • State laws – as of 2016:

Virtually all states have provisions similar to the Pregnancy Discrimination Act in their civil rights laws.

Approximately 12 states have
laws specifically requiring employers to grant a leave of absence for pregnancy disability.

Approximately 17 states have laws requiring accommodation of pregnancy-related conditions in the workplace – even if not a “disability.” “Common conditions of pregnancy” must be accommodated.  Accommodations can include leave of absence as well as breaks, equipment, modified schedules or duties, light duty, etc.

Many more state pregnancy leave and accommodation laws have already been introduced in 2017. Watch this blog for announcements if/when they pass.

Pings for Employers

Treat pregnancy the same as other temporary disabilities – unless a law specifically requires more favorable treatment.

Consider whether your policies and practices provide equal treatment for pregnant employees with regard to:

  • Amount of paid/unpaid leave for a temporary disability.
  • Availability of light duty – it is NOT just for worker’s compensation claimants.
  • Workplace accommodations (equipment, modified duties or schedule, breaks, leave of absence, food or drink
    at a workstation, etc.).
  • Any other term, condition, or benefit of employment.

Also, be familiar with the federal laws identified above and the laws of your state. What protections do they provide for pregnant employees?  What do you need to do to be compliant?

Review the EEOC Enforcement Guidance on Pregnancy Discrimination and Related Issues. Issued in 2014 and revised in 2015; this is a comprehensive guidance regarding treatment of pregnant employees under various federal laws.

UPCOMING EVENT!  I will be presenting at the DMEC Denver Chapter Meeting on the topic “Employers: Beware of Caregiver Protections!” Thursday February 23 at 2:30.  I will address the pregnancy issues discussed above and much more.  Please join me!  Click on the link for more details and to sign up.

For more information on the caregiver topic, see our post What Employers Need to Know about Caregiver Protections under the ADA, FMLA, Title VII… and in California.


MATRIX CAN HELP!  Matrix provides leave, disability, and accommodation management services to employers seeking a comprehensive and compliant solution to these complex employer obligations. We monitor the many leave laws being passed around the country and specialize in understanding how they work together. For leave management and accommodation assistance, contact us at [email protected].